[Registry-dev] Some UI feedback

Glen Daniels glen at wso2.com
Mon Dec 17 09:26:13 PST 2007


Hi folks!

New UI looks great - some issues so far:

* The fact that you click on the slash in the upper left corner to get 
to the root directory is very confusing - and I don't like the fact that 
we end up with a weird looking path because the spacing around the first 
slash is different than subsequent ones.  Can we make it so you get to 
the root by clicking the folder icon instead? Then we can make the paths 
look even also.

* It's unclear what the two rows of rating stars do at first glance.  I 
gather one is for actually rating the resource (and keeping track of 
your rating), and the other is to display the average rating.  I think 
it would be clearer if we had a label "Average rating:" and one set of 
stars on the left, then "My rating:" and another set of stars on the 
right (under "By").  That would also reduce the vertical space.

* The "Information" pane is just too big at first glance, especially 
when you first start with an empty registry pointing to root.  IMHO it 
should start out collapsed.  Also you should be able to click "expand to 
view details" (or maybe anywhere in the collapsed pane) to expand it. 
Also, the info pane should remember if it's collapsed or expanded 
between resources, if possible.

* It's unclear when you've been signed out due to inactivity.  Please 
add an alert for this - otherwise it's very confusing when buttons 
disappear.

* I don't like the placement of the add resource / add directory 
buttons.  I think they should be more prominent, maybe just to the right 
of the current resource path up at the top?

* At present it looks like you can tag anonymously.  I think we should 
remove that and only allow tags from signed-in users.

Thanks,
--Glen



More information about the Registry-dev mailing list